Nov. 5, 2009 -- The popular pain and
fever
reliever acetaminophen may be linked with an increased risk of asthma
in children and adults, according to a new research review of previously
published studies by Canadian researchers.
But the manufacturer of Tylenol® -- the brand-name version of
acetaminophen -- says the painkiller has a well-established safety record.
Researchers pooled the results of 19
clinical studies, with a total of more than 425,000 participants, to see if the
association between the pain reliever use and asthma (and wheezing in children) held up. It did.
What triggered the review? "Concern over the
risk of acetaminophen and asthma highlighted
by the 2008 ISAAC study, published in The Lancet," says the
review's lead author Mahyar Etminan, PharmD, a scientist at the Vancouver
Coastal Health Research Institute in British Columbia and an assistant
professor of medicine at the University of British Columbia.
In the ISAAC (International Study of
Asthma and Allergies in Childhood) study, researchers
looked at more than 205,000 children, ages 6 to 7, in 31 countries and found
that acetaminophen use for fever in the first year of life was linked to
increased risk of asthma symptoms in children 6 to 7 years old. Current use of
acetaminophen was also linked to increased risk of asthma symptoms.
Other studies, Etminan says, have
produced conflicting results, so the Canadian team conducted the review. {This has to be bull-shit by an industry
representative, for the percentage increase is far too great for there to be
fundamentally conflicting results.
Conflicting results probably mean other studies find a different
percentage of increase--jk.}
Sales of acetaminophen
products in the U.S. are about $1 billion annually, the researchers estimate.
Calculating
Asthma Risk
Etminan's team searched the medical
literature to find high-quality published studies, trying to quantify the risk
of asthma and wheezing among acetaminophen users, as well as the effect of
prenatal exposure to the medicine.
After eliminating studies that
weren't scientifically sound enough, the researchers focused on 19 studies.
Overall, they found that acetaminophen users were 63% more likely to have
asthma than nonusers. Other findings:
- The
risk of asthma in children given acetaminophen in the year before their
asthma diagnosis was increased by 60%.
- The
risk of asthma in children who used acetaminophen in the first year of
life was 47% higher than in those who didn't use it.
- The
risk of asthma in adults who used acetaminophen was 74% higher than in
those who did not.
- Prenatal
use of acetaminophen boosted the risk of wheezing by 50% and the risk of
asthma by 28% in children.
The researchers concede that
children with severe asthma may be more likely to get acetaminophen for viral
or other infections that may actually be due to asthma or may precede an asthma
diagnosis.
The finding of acetaminophen use and
asthma is an association, they say, but not necessarily a cause and effect.
The researchers say other mechanisms
may explain the link. Acetaminophen, they say, may boost an enzyme involved in
the anti-inflammatory response in asthma.
There are other possible mechanisms.
''There isn't enough evidence to favor one over the other," Etminan says.
He says more studies are needed to fully understand the association.
Drugmaker's
Perspective
In a prepared statement, McNeil
Consumer Healthcare, which makes Tylenol®, says:
TYLENOL® (acetaminophen) has over 50
years of clinical history to support its safety and efficacy and, when used as
labeled, TYLENOL® has a superior safety profile compared with many other
over-the-counter (OTC) pain relievers. The well-documented safety profile for
acetaminophen makes it the preferred pain reliever for asthma sufferers." {This more bull shit, for acetaminophen is
the leading cause of drug induced liver failure, and is why some medications
with it have been pulled in other countries such as Britain--jk.}
The statement continues: "There
are no prospective, randomized controlled studies that show a causal link
between acetaminophen and asthma. The systematic review and meta-analysis
published in Chest does not establish a definitive casual relationship
between the therapeutic use of acetaminophen and an increased risk of asthma
and wheezing in both children and adults. In fact, the study investigators
admit that their systematic review is subject to several limitations, one of
which is that diagnosis of asthma in most of the studies was through
self-reporting and the possibility of misclassification of asthma with other
respiratory conditions can't be excluded. The authors also stated that
additional studies would be needed in order to verify their findings.'' {Would you want your child to be in a study
to see if acetaminophen causes asthma--jk?}
Second
Opinion
Another expert said the review is
strong. "This is clearly synthesizing the studies that have been conducted
over the past 10 years and is showing the emerging evidence that acetaminophen
seems to be associated with the development of asthma and asthma-like symptoms
in children and adults," says Matt Perzanowski, PhD, assistant professor
of environmental health sciences at the Mailman School of Public Health at
Columbia University in New York.
With his colleagues at Columbia,
Perzanowski recently found that prenatal acetaminophen exposure boosts the risk
of wheezing in inner city, minority children (who have high rates of asthma) at
age 5.
They believe that children with a
genetic mutation affecting an antioxidant that helps ''detox'' the body may be
the ones at risk, Perzanowski tells WebMD.
A practicing allergist, Rebecca G.
Piltch, MD, who cares for patients with asthma and allergies in Marin County,
Calif., says the association is interesting but points out it does not prove
cause and effect. {Neither does the
statistics which show that 85% of lung cancer is with those who smoke--jk}
Perzanowski agrees, saying:
"There is still a possibility the association is due to some other
mechanism besides the acetaminophen."
{Not with cigarette-like percentage of increase--jk.}
Until more research is done, what's
a parent or adult to do? "The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends
acetaminophen as the drug of choice for controlling fever," Etminan says.
"Parents should still follow these guidelines until the recommendations
change."
"For adults, ibuprofen is an alternative drug that can be
used," he says. "Unlike acetaminophen, ibuprofen has not been shown
to be associated with asthma."
Following the recommended dose is
important, he says. The question of whether a specific dose is linked with the
risk of asthma needs to be studied, Etminan says.
Patients already diagnosed with
asthma should check with their own doctor about acetaminophen use, Piltch says.
Those who don't have asthma ''but have concerns about acetaminophen should
discuss them with their primary care provider."
SOURCES:
Mahyar Etminan, PharmD, scientist, Center for Clinical Epidemiology and
Evaluation, Vancouver Coastal Health Research Institute; assistant professor of
medicine, University of British Columbia, Canada.
Etminan, M. Chest, November, 2009; vol 135: pp 1316-1323.
Beasley, R. The Lancet, Sept. 20, 2008; vol 372: pp 1039-1048.
Perzanowski, M. Thorax, published online Oct. 22, 2009.
Matt Perzanowski, PhD, assistant professor of environmental health sciences,
Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University.
Rebecca G. Piltch, MD, allergist and immunologist, Marin County, Calif.
Marc Boston, McNeil Consumer Healthcare.
© 2009 WebMD, LLC. All rights reserved.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Asthma
increased 63% for
14 times a day or more
American
Journal of
Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine
Am. J. Respir.
Crit. Care Med., Volume 169, Number 7, April 2004, 836-841
A more
recent version of this
article appeared on April 1, 2004
Prospective Study of
Acetaminophen Use and Newly Diagnosed Asthma among Women
R. Graham Barr1*, Catherine C Wentowski2, Gary C Curhan3, Samuel C Somers2, Meir J Stampfer3, Joel Schwartz4, Frank E Speizer4, and Carlos A Camargo5
Acetaminophen decreases glutathione levels in the lung, which may predispose to
oxidative injury and bronchospasm. Acetaminophen use has been
associated with asthma in cross-sectional and birth-cohort studies. We
hypothesized that acetaminophen use would be associated with newly
diagnosed adult-onset asthma in the Nurses
Health Study,
a prospective cohort study of 121,700 women. Participants were first asked
about frequency of acetaminophen use in 1990.Asthma cases were defined as new physician
diagnosis of asthma between 1990 and 1996, plus reiteration of the
diagnosis and controller medication use. Proportional hazard
models included age, race, socioeconomic status, body mass index,
smoking, other analgesic use and postmenopausal hormone use.
During 352,719 person-years of follow-up, 346 participants
reported a new physician diagnosis of asthma meeting diagnostic criteria.
Increasing frequency of acetaminophen use was positively
associated with newly diagnosed asthma (P-trend = 0.006). The
multivariate rate ratio for asthma for participants who took
acetaminophen for more than 14 days per month was 1.63
(95% CI 1.11-2.39)compared to
non-users. It would be premature to recommend acetaminophen avoidance for
patients with asthma, but further research on pulmonary responses
to acetaminophen is necessary to confirm or refute these
findings and to identify subgroups whose asthma may be modified by
acetaminophen.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Meta study, pooled risk increase 63%, children 60%. Plausible
mechanisms to explain this association include depletion of pulmonary
glutathione and oxidative stress.
http://chestjournal.chestpubs.org/content/136/5/1316.short
Acetaminophen Use and the Risk of Asthma in Children and Adults
A Systematic
Review and Metaanalysis
1.
Mahyar Etminan, PharmD, MSc, Mohsen Sadatsafavi, MD, MHSc,
Siavash Jafari, MD, MHSc,
Mimi Doyle-Waters, MSc, Kevin Aminzadeh, DDS and
J. Mark FitzGerald, MD, FCCP
Abstract
Background: Epidemiologic studies have
identified an increased risk of asthma with acetaminophen use, but the results
have been conflicting. We sought to quantify the association between
acetaminophen use and the risk of asthma in children and adults.
Methods: We searched all the major
medical databases, including MEDLINE (from 1966 to 2008) and EMBASE (from 1980
to 2008) to identify pertinent articles. All clinical trials and observational
studies were considered. For observational studies, we selected those that clearly
defined acetaminophen use and asthma diagnosis. Study quality was assessed by
two reviewers, and data were extracted into a spreadsheet. A random-effects
model was used to combine studies with asthma and wheezing among both children
and adults.
Results: Thirteen cross-sectional
studies, four cohort studies, and two case-control studies comprising 425,140
subjects were included in the review. The pooled odds ratio (OR) for asthma
among subjects using acetaminophen was 1.63 (95% CI, 1.46 to 1.77). The risk of
asthma in children among users of acetaminophen in the year prior to asthma
diagnosis and within the first year of life was elevated (OR: 1.60 [95% CI,
1.48 to 1.74] and 1.47 [95% CI, 1.36 to 1.56], respectively). Only one study
reported the association between high acetaminophen dose and asthma in children
(OR, 3.23; 95% CI, 2.9 to 3.6). There was an increase in the risk of asthma and
wheezing with prenatal use of acetaminophen (OR: 1.28 [95% CI, 1.16 to 41] and
1.50 [95% CI, 1.10 to 2.05], respectively).
Conclusions: The results of our review are
consistent with an increase in the risk of asthma and wheezing in both children
and adults exposed to acetaminophen. Future studies are needed to confirm these
results.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Chest: 10.1378/chest.127.2.604CHEST February 2005 vol. 127 no. 2 604-612 http://chestjournal.chestpubs.org/content/127/2/604.full
Acetaminophen and the Risk of Asthma*
The
Epidemiologic and Pathophysiologic Evidence
1.
Ihuoma Eneli, MD, MS,
2.
Katayoun Sadri, MD,
3.
Carlos Camargo Jr, MD, DrPH, FCCP and
4.
R. Graham Barr, MD, DrPH
The prevalence of asthma in the United States has risen by 75%
in the last 3 decades, with a particularly marked increase in children < 5
years of age (160%).1This rise transcends age, gender, ethnicity, and geographic
location, but affects minority groups, the socioeconomically disadvantaged, and
inner-city populations disproportionately. The reason for the surge in
prevalence is unclear. A number of hypotheses have been proposed, including
increased environmental exposures to “synthetic” materials and indoor
allergens, decreased exposure to bacteria and childhood illnesses (the
“hygiene” hypothesis), the increasing prevalence of obesity, changes in diet
and antioxidant intake, increased exposure to cockroaches, changing
meteorological patterns, and decreased use of aspirin.23456789 In addition, cytokine
imbalance or dysregulation occurring as a result of environmental exposures
during infancy and early childhood is hypothesized
to induce lifelong T-helper type 2 (allergic) dominance over T-helper type 1 (nonallergic)
responses. T-helper type 2 dominance increases the risk for atopic diseases,
including asthma.4610 While most studies467 have focused on the effects of these factors after birth, some610 have suggested sensitization in
utero.
A link
between acetaminophen and bronchoconstriction was originally suggested in a
case report of an aspirin-intolerant patient as early as 1967 by Chafee and
Settipane.11 Recently, with the rise in
asthma prevalence, there has been renewed interest in the role of
acetaminophen. Acetaminophen, found frequently in combination with other drugs
such as opiates and cold/cough formulations, is the most common form of
analgesia used in the United States, particularly in children.12 Kogan et al12 estimated that approximately two thirds of
analgesia used over a 30-day period by US preschool-aged children was
acetaminophen. Concurrent with the use of acetaminophen, a large increase in
asthma, particularly in the pediatric population, has been reported.1 This review will summarize
and evaluate the epidemiologic and pathophysiologic evidence underlying the
hypothesis that acetaminophen is a risk factor for asthma and may have
contributed to the recent increase in asthma prevalence.
Previous SectionNext Section
Materials and Methods
Across European countries, asthma rates have been ecologically
associated with acetaminophen use.29 This study by Newson et al29 was the first large
epidemiologic study to suggest a link between asthma and acetaminophen. Using
data from the International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood and the
European Community Respiratory Health Survey (ECHRIS), the authors observed a positive
correlation between acetaminophen sales and asthma symptoms, eczema, and
allergic rhinoconjunctivitis at the country level. For each gram increase in
per capita paracetamol sales in 1994/1995, the prevalence of wheeze increased
by 0.52% among 13- to 14-year-old subjects in the International Study of Asthma
and Allergies in Childhood study. Similarly, wheezing rose by 0.26% (p =
0.0005) per gram increase among young adults surveyed in ECHRIS. The results
parallel comparative prevalence trends of asthma noted since acetaminophen
became the primary over-the-counter analgesic. While ecologic findings such as
these are helpful for the description of group-level (in this case,
country-level) patterns of association, inferences about individuals (or patients)
cannot be surmised.
The
association between asthma and acetaminophen has also been seen at the
individual level. In a large population-based, case-control study30 of young adults (n = 1,574),
daily and weekly use of acetaminophen was strongly associated with asthma.
Acetaminophen exposure was defined only by frequency of intake. There was a
significant trend comparing acetaminophen users: never users, infrequent users (less
than monthly), monthly users, weekly and daily users (p = 0.0002), and
self-reported history of asthma. In a multivariate regression analysis
controlling for sex, age, social class, type of accommodation, employment and
parental status, other analgesic use, and smoking and passive smoke exposure,
acetaminophen use was positively associated with asthma (odds ratio [OR], 1.79;
95% confidence interval [CI], 1.21 to 2.65). The relationship was much stronger
for severe asthma (OR, 8.2; 95% CI, 2.8 to 23). Aspirin avoidance did not
appear to account for the positive results, as the association was found in
those taking only acetaminophen as well as in those taking both analgesics.
Limitations in the study included an overall response rate of 50%, with lower enrollment
in younger persons, current smokers, and men, hence introducing selection bias,
as acetaminophen use may differ among these groups. The study did not account
for factors such as headaches and respiratory tract infections, which may lead
to increased use of acetaminophen among asthmatic patients. Furthermore, given
the cross-sectional design of the study, it is unclear if acetaminophen
contributed to asthma or vice versa.
A recent
report from the Nurses’ Health Study,31 a prospective cohort study of
121,700 women (age range, 30 to 55 years) in 1976, found that increased
frequency of acetaminophen use in 1990 to 1992 was associated with a subsequent
risk of physician diagnosis of new-onset asthma diagnosed between 1990 and 1996
(adjusted relative risk [RR], 1.63; 95% CI, 1.11 to 2.39; p = 0.006 for trend).
The positive association remained unchanged whether the participants used or
did not use aspirin. In multivariate analysis adjusting for a variety of
potential confounders including body mass index, osteoarthritis, and frequency
of physician visits, aspirin was inversely associated with newly diagnosed
asthma (p = 0.03 for trend), but no association was seen with nonsteroidal
antiinflammatory drugs (p = 0.12 for trend). The results, however, are
difficult to generalize to other ethnic groups, ages, or gender as the study
was carried out in an older, female, predominantly white population.
The only
published study32 to examine acetaminophen use
during pregnancy and the risk of wheezing in offspring was conducted in Great
Britain. Analgesic intake (aspirin and acetaminophen) was ascertained using
questionnaires at 18 to 20 weeks and 32 weeks of gestation among 9,400 women
participating in the Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children. The study
population represented 64% of the original cohort. Following adjustment for
potential confounders such as family history of atopy, family size, antibiotic
use, daycare attendance, environmental tobacco exposure, and anthropometric
measures, the risk of wheezing was increased twofold in 30-to 42-month-old
children whose mothers frequently used acetaminophen prenatally during weeks 20
to 32 of gestation. This association was stronger if the child had wheezed
before 6 months (OR, 2.34; 95% CI, 1.24 to 4.40). Excluding infants with a
maternal history of asthma did not change the results. Mothers who used aspirin
frequently (most days/daily) were also more likely to have infants who wheezed
within the first 6 months of life (OR, 2.73; 95% CI, 1.57 to 4.76), suggesting
either a nonspecific effect or that important confounders may not have been
considered. Since the prevalence of acetaminophen use in this study was only
approximately 1.5%, the population-attributable risk fraction for acetaminophen
use during pregnancy and wheeze in the offspring is only 0.9%. The low
population-attributable risk fraction negates any recommendations to change
acetaminophen as the analgesia of choice during pregnancy.
Lesko and Mitchell33 conducted a double-blinded
randomized clinical trial to determine the safety of ibuprofen in children. The
trial compared ibuprofen with acetaminophen for treatment of pediatric febrile
illness among 84,000 children, but did not have a placebo study arm. Among
1,879 children with a physician diagnosis of asthma who received daily asthma
medication, the risk of having an outpatient visit for asthma was significantly
lower in children assigned to the ibuprofen group compared with the
acetaminophen group (RR, 0.56; 95% CI, 0.34 to 0.95).81 Children who received
ibuprofen also had lower rates of hospitalization than those who received
acetaminophen, although it was not statistically significant (RR, 0.63; 95% CI,
0.25 to 1.6). With the lack of a placebo group in this study, it is unclear whether
ibuprofen reduced the risk of asthma, acetaminophen increased the risk, or a
combination of both occurred. Although this study did not primarily seek to
examine the association between asthma and acetaminophen, the size and rigor of
the study design (randomized clinical trial) provides a measure of confidence
for validity of the results.
Multiple case reports, case series, and oral challenge tests34353637383940414243444546474849 have described respiratory
symptoms and acute declines in respiratory function indexes following ingestion
of acetaminophen among both aspirin-sensitive and aspirin-tolerant patients.
While studies summarized in Table 2 do
not support the premise that increased acetaminophen use has led to the rise in
asthma prevalence, they provide evidence of potentially deleterious effects of
acetaminophen on respiratory function among selected individuals. Schwarz and
Ham Pong37 reported a > 20% fall in
FEV1 and FVC in a 13-year-old,
aspirin-sensitive patient challenged with 325 mg of acetaminophen, while an
Australian study43 reported bronchoconstriction
and anaphylaxis in five aspirin-tolerant patients with doses ranging from 500
to 1,000 mg. In sequential challenge tests with 1,000 mg and 1500 mg of
acetaminophen among 50 aspirin-sensitive patients, 34% of the patients had at
least a 15% decline in FEV1 compared with none of the
non–aspirin-sensitive control subjects (p = 0.0013).39 Cross-reactivity with
acetaminophen is estimated in 20 to 30% of aspirin-sensitive asthmatics.40 The severity of asthma at the
time of drug ingestion, rather than the dose ingested, appears to be a better
indicator of likelihood of a reaction to acetaminophen.383940 Reports of respiratory
reactions have also been found in reviews of drug registries.42 Of 68 adverse reaction
reports that could be causally linked to acetaminophen in the Australian Drug
registry,41 15 patients presented with
bronchoconstriction. However, since registries rely on passive reporting
mechanisms, these numbers may severely underestimate the incidence of adverse
drug reactions.50 Furthermore, estimates may be
particularly low for established, commonly used, or over-the-counter drugs.
Acetaminophen, Glutathione, and Lung Inflammation
Glutathione (L-gamma-glutamyl-L-cysteinyl glycine) is found in
respiratory tract lining fluid, of which > 95% is present in the reduced
form as an antioxidant.51Glutathione has been implicated in lung inflammation in a number
of studies.535764 Compared with healthy
children, glutathione has been detected at lower levels in the exhaled breath
condensate of asthmatic children during exacerbations.52 Some studies report reduced
glutathione peroxidase activity in platelets and whole blood in asthmatic and
atopic patients, suggesting impairment of the glutathione redox system in
handling reactive oxygen species; others have found no relationship.53545556 Genetic polymorphisms of
glutathione-S-transferase enzyme systems, which counteract products of oxidant
stress, have also been detected in asthmatic patients.5758 Asthmatic children who are
homozygous for specific allele variants have significantly lower values for
FVC, FEV1, and maximal mid-expiratory flow than children without asthma.58
Acetaminophen decreases glutathione levels, principally in the
liver and kidneys, but also in the lungs.5960 These decreases are dose
dependent: overdose levels of acetaminophen are cytotoxic to pneumocytes and
cause acute lung injury,61whereas nontoxic, therapeutic doses produce smaller, but
significant reductions in glutathione levels in type II pneumocytes and
alveolar macrophages.62 Among healthy young
volunteers, significantly lower serum antioxidant capacity has been seen within
2 weeks of ingestion of 1 gm of acetaminophen.63 By depleting glutathione
levels, acetaminophen weakens the ability of the host to mitigate oxidative
stress produced by reactive oxygen species (ROS) such as superoxide anions (O2-), hydroxyl (•OH), and peroxyl
(ROO−) radicals.515364 ROS are formed either by loss
or gain of a single electron from a nonradical produced by inflammatory cells.
They then trigger a cascade of epithelial desquamation, edema, release of
leukotrienes, bronchoconstriction, and stimulation of additional inflammatory
cells.
ROS and their metabolites oxidize phospholipids within the cell
membrane through a sequence of initiation, propagation, and termination, a
process termedlipid peroxidation. Arachidonic acid, a major building block for prostaglandins
and leukotrienes, two key inflammatory mediators in asthma, is released from
membrane phospholipids through lipid peroxidation. This process damages the
integrity of the cell membrane or the nucleus, ultimately resulting in cell
death. Generation of ROS products have been correlated with airway inflammation
and nocturnal asthma,6566 and oxygen radicals have also
been implicated in bronchial smooth-muscle contraction in dogs, cows, and
guinea pigs.6768
Eosinophils, also inflammatory mediators in asthma, not only generate
oxygen radicals but release an enzyme, eosinophil peroxidase, which potentiates
cytotoxic effects on type II pneumocytes.69 Wu et al70 identified a new
oxidant-mediated pathway for lung injury through bromination of tyrosine
residues by the eosinophil peroxidase-H2O2 system in the presence of
plasma levels of halides.
An unlikely mechanism in the glutathione depletion theory is
through the hepatic P450 cytochrome pathway, a system that metabolizes
acetaminophen. The end product of this metabolic pathway,
N-acetyl-p-benzoquinonemine, is conjugated by glutathione into a harmless
substance. When glutathione is depleted, N-acetyl-p-benzoquinonemine
accumulates and arylates cellular macromolecules, resulting in cell death. The
ability of the liver to remove these toxic intermediates is exceeded when an
overdose occurs; however, occasional toxicity has been reported with
therapeutic doses in certain circumstances, eg, alcoholics.7172 The critical period of injury
occurs during the glutathione resynthesis process when levels remain low.51 Dimova et al62 demonstrated damage to rodent
type II pneumocytes and alveolar macrophages following exposure to doses
comparable to human therapeutic levels of acetaminophen. These effects were
more pronounced in type II pneumocytes, which are particularly vulnerable
because of their P450 cytochrome and prostaglandin synthase systems, which are
involved in the metabolism of acetaminophen.
Finally, when glutathione levels are low, defective processing
of disulfide bonds that are key in antigen presentation has been hypothesized.7374 It is conceivable that
decreased levels of glutathione guide the expression of T-helper cell pathways
by altering antigen presentation and recognition, thereby favoring the T2
allergic dominant pathway. Clearly, glutathione is a versatile molecule,
assuming different roles in multiple metabolic pathways; however, this
characteristic highlights gaps in our understanding of the glutathione
depletion hypothesis and the lack of a single mechanism of action.
Contradictory results from studies using nebulized glutathione
(granted there are only two studies) illustrate the difficulty with this
hypothesis. A double-blind, cross-over study of eight patients with mild asthma
receiving nebulized glutathione and saline solution as a placebo, found glutathione
induced a decline of 19% in FEV1 and increased total pulmonary
resistance by 61%. Bagnato et al75found the contrary, reporting a protective effect of glutathione
on FEV1 following a “fog” challenge
using nebulized distilled water in 12 patients with mild-to-moderate asthma.
Glutathione is not only a scavenger for ROS, but has also been implicated in
the formation of leukotriene C4 and D4, both potent bronchoconstrictors. Furthermore, the period of
glutathione resynthesis in the lungs is very short, making it unlikely that
significant oxidative stress likely to cause asthma can occur within such a
short window of time. The role of ROS in lung injury, counteracting systems,
particularly glutathione, has generated significant interest and may present a
plausible mechanism. However, ROS have been implicated in a wide range of
disorders, thereby weakening the specificity of this mechanism for true
causality.
Cyclooxygenase Pathway
Another hypothesized mechanism unrelated to glutathione involves
the cyclooxygenase-2 receptors and other yet-to-be defined cyclooxygenase
receptors. Acetaminophen may well exert an effect on the lungs mediated by the
lack of suppression of cyclooxygenase, an inflammatory pathway.
Cyclooxygenase-2 promotes the production of prostaglandin E2. Prostaglandin E2tilts the immunologic process in favor of a T-helper type 2
response, while inhibiting T-helper type 1 lymphocytes, thus establishing an
allergic tendency in the immune response to various antigenic stimuli.976
IgE-Mediated Pathway
The least developed of the hypotheses involves an IgE-mediated
mechanism with acetaminophen as the antigenic agent.1548 Using four aspirin and
nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drug-tolerant patients and 30 matched control
subjects, de Paramo et al15 conducted skin-prick tests
and measured acetaminophen-specific serum IgE levels following an oral
challenge of 250 mg and 500 mg of acetaminophen. Both the control subjects and
patients tolerated oral challenges with 250 and 500 mg aspirin. Following
ingestion of acetaminophen, elevated IgE levels and positive skin-prick test
findings were noted in two of the four patients, but not in the control
subjects. Only one patient had both high IgE levels and positive skin-prick
test results. In addition, two studies1649 have shown elevated levels of
histamine, a key chemical mediator in the IgE-triggered cascade of inflammation
seen in asthma. While this may be an intuitively appealing hypothesis, our
understanding of the pathogenesis of other analgesia-induced asthma does not
lend credence to this mechanism. For example, the ASA triad (aspirin
sensitivity, asthma, and nasal polyps) is thought to arise not from an
IgE-mediated pathway, but rather hypersensitivity to inhibition of the
cyclooxygenase pathway.76 Finally, it is possible, but
unlikely, that an excipient in the acetaminophen formulations is responsible
for these reactions.
References
1.
↵
Mannino, DM,
Homa, DM, Pertowski, CA, et al (1998) Surveillance for asthma:
United States, 1960–1995. MMWR CDC Surveill Summ 47,1-27
Medline
2.
↵
Camargo, CA,
Jr, Weiss, JT, Zhang, S, et al Prospective study of body mass index, weight
change, and risk of adult-onset asthma in women. Arch Intern Med 1999;159,2582-2588
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
3.
↵
Platts-Mills,
TA The role of allergens in the induction of asthma. Curr Allergy Asthma Rep 2002;2,175-180
Medline
4.
↵
Platts-Mills,
T, Vaughan, J, Squillace, S, et al Sensitisation, asthma, and a modified Th2
response in children exposed to cat allergen: a population-based
cross-sectional study. Lancet 2001;357,752-756
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
5.
↵
Soutar, A,
Seaton, A, Brown, K Bronchial reactivity and dietary antioxidants. Thorax 1997;52,166-170
Abstract
6.
↵
Sporik, R,
Platts-Mills, TA Allergen exposure and the development of asthma. Thorax 2001;56(suppl),ii58-ii63
7.
↵
Sporik, R,
Squillace, SP, Ingram, JM, et al Mite, cat, and cockroach exposure, allergen
sensitization, and asthma in children: a case-control study of three schools. Thorax 1999;54,675-680
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
8.
↵
Goldsmith,
JR, Friger, MD, Abramson, M Associations between health and air pollution in
time-series analyses. Arch Environ Health 1996;51,359-367
MedlineWeb
of Science
9.
↵
Varner, AE,
Busse, WW, Lemanske, RF, Jr Hypothesis: decreased use of pediatric aspirin has
contributed to the increasing prevalence of childhood asthma. Ann Allergy Asthma Immunol 1998;81,347-351
MedlineWeb
of Science
10.
↵
Devereux, G,
Barker, RN, Seaton, A Antenatal determinants of neonatal immune responses to
allergens. Clin Exp Allergy 2002;32,43-50
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
11.
↵
Chafee, FH,
Settipane, GA Asthma caused by FD&C approved dyes. J Allergy 1967;40,65-72
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
12.
↵
Kogan, MD,
Pappas, G, Yu, SM, et al Over-the-counter medication use among US preschool-age
children. JAMA 1994;272,1025-1030
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
13.
↵
Karakaya, G,
Kalyoncu, AF Paracetamol and asthma. Expert Opin Pharmacother 2003;4,13-21
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
14.
↵
Bachmeyer, C,
Vermeulen, C, Habki, R, et al Acetaminophen (paracetamol)-induced anaphylactic
shock. South Med J 2002;95,759-760
MedlineWeb
of Science
15.
↵
de Paramo,
BJ, Gancedo, SQ, Cuevas, M, et al Paracetamol (acetaminophen) hypersensitivity. Ann Allergy Asthma Immunol 2000;85,508-511
MedlineWeb
of Science
16.
↵
Doan, T,
Greenberger, PA Nearly fatal episodes of hypotension, flushing, and dyspnea in
a 47-year-old woman. Ann Allergy 1993;70,439-444
MedlineWeb
of Science
17.
↵
Furness, J,
Macdonald, F Paracetamol and asthma [letter]. Thorax2000;55,882
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
18.
↵
Ho, SW,
Beilin, LJ Asthma associated with N-acetylcysteine infusion and paracetamol
poisoning: report of two cases. BMJ (Clin Res Ed)1983;287,876-877
FREE Full
Text
19.
↵
Kalyoncu, AF,
Kisacik, G, Sahin, AA, et al Prevalence of cross-sensitivity with acetaminophen
and other nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs in asthmatic patients. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1996;98,713-714
MedlineWeb
of Science
20.
↵
Karakaya, G,
Demir, AU, Kalyoncu, AF Paracetamol and asthma [letter].Thorax 2001;56,586
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
21.
↵
Kumar, RK, Byard,
I Paracetamol as a cause of anaphylaxis. Hosp Med1999;60,66-67
MedlineWeb
of Science
22.
↵
Martin, JA,
Lazaro, M, Cuevas, M, et al Paracetamol anaphylaxis [letter].Clin Exp Allergy 1993;23,534
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
23.
↵
Mendizabal,
SL, Diez Gomez, ML Paracetamol sensitivity without aspirin intolerance. Allergy 1998;53,457-458
MedlineWeb
of Science
24.
↵
Shin, GY,
Dargan, P, Jones, AL Paracetamol and asthma [letter]. Thorax2000;55,882
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
25.
↵
Vidal, C, Perez-Carral,
C, Gonzalez-Quintela, A Paracetamol (acetaminophen) hypersensitivity. Ann Allergy Asthma Immunol1997;79,320-321
MedlineWeb
of Science
26.
↵
Vale, JA, Buckley,
BM Asthma associated with N-acetylcysteine infusion and paracetamol poisoning
[letter]. BMJ (Clin Res Ed) 1983;287,1223
FREE Full
Text
27.
↵
Ownby, DR
Acetaminophen-induced urticaria and tolerance of ibuprofen in an eight-year-old
child. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1997;99,151-152
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
28.
↵
Ibanez, MD,
Alonso, E, Munoz, MC, et al Delayed hypersensitivity reaction to paracetamol
(acetaminophen). Allergy 1996;51,121-123
MedlineWeb
of Science
29.
↵
Newson, RB,
Shaheen, SO, Chinn, S, et al Paracetamol sales and atopic disease in children
and adults: an ecological analysis. Eur Respir J2000;16,817-823
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
30.
↵
Shaheen, SO,
Sterne, JA, Songhurst, CE, et al Frequent paracetamol use and asthma in adults. Thorax 2000;55,266-270
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
31.
↵
Barr, RG,
Wentowski, CC, Curhan, GC, et al Prospective study of acetaminophen use and
newly diagnosed asthma among women. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2004;169,836-841
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
32.
↵
Shaheen, SO,
Newson, RB, Sherriff, A, et al Paracetamol use in pregnancy and wheezing in
early childhood. Thorax 2002;57,958-963
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
33.
↵
Lesko, SM,
Mitchell, AA The safety of acetaminophen and ibuprofen among children younger
than two years old. Pediatrics 1999;104,e39
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
34.
↵
Kivity, S,
Pawlik, I, Katz, Y Acetaminophen hypersensitivity. Allergy1999;54,187-188
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
35.
↵
Szczeklik, A,
Gryglewski, RJ, Czerniawska-Mysik, G Relationship of inhibition of
prostaglandin biosynthesis by analgesics to asthma attacks in aspirin-sensitive
patients. BMJ 1975;1,67-69
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
36.
↵
Szczeklik, A,
Gryglewski, RJ, Czerniawska-Mysik, G Clinical patterns of hypersensitivity to
nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs and their pathogenesis. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1977;60,276-284
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
37.
↵
Schwarz, N,
Ham Pong, A Acetaminophen anaphylaxis with aspirin and sodium salicylate
sensitivity: a case report. Ann Allergy Asthma Immunol1996;77,473-474
MedlineWeb
of Science
38.
↵
Falliers, CJ
Acetaminophen and aspirin challenges in subgroups of asthmatics. J Asthma 1983;20(Suppl 1),39-49
Medline
39.
↵
Settipane,
RA, Schrank, PJ, Simon, RA, et al Prevalence of cross-sensitivity with
acetaminophen in aspirin-sensitive asthmatic subjects. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1995;96,480-485
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
40.
↵
Settipane,
RA, Stevenson, DD Cross sensitivity with acetaminophen in aspirin-sensitive
subjects with asthma. J Allergy Clin Immunol 1989;84,26-33
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
41.
↵
Ayonrinde,
OT, Saker, BM Anaphylactoid reactions to paracetamol.Postgrad Med J 2000;76,501-502
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
42.
↵
Stricker, BH,
Meyboom, RH, Lindquist, M Acute hypersensitivity reactions to paracetamol. BMJ (Clin Res Ed) 1985;291,938-939
FREE Full
Text
43.
↵
Leung, R,
Plomley, R, Czarny, D Paracetamol anaphylaxis. Clin Exp Allergy1992;22,831-833
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
44.
↵
Grant, JA,
Weiler, JM A report of a rare immediate reaction after ingestion of
acetaminophen. Ann Allergy Asthma Immunol 2001;87,227-229
MedlineWeb
of Science
45.
↵
Spector, SL,
Wangaard, CH, Farr, RS Aspirin and concomitant idiosyncrasies in adult
asthmatic patients. J Allergy Clin Immunol1979;64,500-506
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
46.
↵
Ellis, M, Haydik,
I, Gillman, S, et al Immediate adverse reactions to acetaminophen in children:
evaluation of histamine release and spirometry. J Pediatr 1989;114,654-656
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
47.
↵
Fischer, TJ,
Guilfoile, TD, Kesarwala, HH, et al Adverse pulmonary responses to aspirin and
acetaminophen in chronic childhood asthma.Pediatrics 1983;71,313-318
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
48.
↵
Galindo, PA,
Borja, J, Mur, P, et al Anaphylaxis to paracetamol. Allergol Immunopathol (Madr) 1998;26,199-200
Medline
49.
↵
Van Diem, L,
Grilliat, JP Anaphylactic shock induced by paracetamol. Eur J Clin Pharmacol 1990;38,389-390
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
50.
↵
Talbot, JC,
Nilsson, BS Pharmacovigilance in the pharmaceutical industry.Br J Clin Pharmacol 1998;45,427-431
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
51.
↵
Kelly, FJ
Glutathione: in defense of the lung. Food Chem Toxicol1999;37,963-966
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
52.
↵
Corradi, M,
Folesani, G, Andreoli, R, et al Aldehydes and glutathione in exhaled breath
condensate of children with asthma exacerbation. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2003;167,395-399
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
53.
↵
Rahman, I,
MacNee, W Oxidative stress and regulation of glutathione in lung inflammation. Eur Respir J 2000;16,534-554
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
54.
↵
Powell, CV,
Nash, AA, Powers, HJ, et al Antioxidant status in asthma.Pediatr Pulmonol 1994;18,34-38
MedlineWeb
of Science
55.
↵
Plaza, V,
Prat, J, Rosello, J, et al In vitro release of arachidonic acid
metabolites, glutathione peroxidase, and oxygen-free radicals from platelets of
asthmatic patients with and without aspirin intolerance. Thorax1995;50,490-496
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
56.
↵
Misso, NL,
Powers, KA, Gillon, RL, et al Reduced platelet glutathione peroxidase activity
and serum selenium concentration in atopic asthmatic patients. Clin Exp Allergy 1996;26,838-847
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
57.
↵
Fryer, AA, Bianco,
A, Hepple, M, et al Polymorphism at the glutathione S-transferase GSTP1 locus:
a new marker for bronchial hyperresponsiveness and asthma. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2000;161,1437-1442
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
58.
↵
Gilliland,
FD, Gauderman, WJ, Vora, H, et al Effects of glutathione-S-transferase M1, T1,
and P1 on childhood lung function growth. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 2002;166,710-716
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
59.
↵
Chen, TS,
Richie, JP, Jr, Lang, CA Life span profiles of glutathione and acetaminophen
detoxification. Drug Metab Dispos 1990;18,882-887
Abstract
60.
↵
Micheli, L,
Cerretani, D, Fiaschi, AI, et al Effect of acetaminophen on glutathione levels
in rat testis and lung. Environ Health Perspect1994;102(Suppl 9),63-64
Medline
61.
↵
Baudouin, SV,
Howdle, P, O’Grady, JG, et al Acute lung injury in fulminant hepatic failure
following paracetamol poisoning. Thorax 1995;50,399-402
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
62.
↵
Dimova, S,
Hoet, PH, Nemery, B Paracetamol (acetaminophen) cytotoxicity in rat type II
pneumocytes and alveolar macrophages in vitro. Biochem Pharmacol 2000;59,1467-1475
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
63.
↵
Nuttall, SL,
Khan, JN, Thorpe, GH, et al The impact of therapeutic doses of paracetamol on
serum total antioxidant capacity. J Clin Pharm Ther2003;28,289-294
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
64.
↵
Smith, LJ,
Anderson, J, Shamsuddin, M, et al Effect of fasting on hyperoxic lung injury in
mice: the role of glutathione. Am Rev Respir Dis1990;141,141-149
MedlineWeb
of Science
65.
↵
Jarjour, NN,
Calhoun, WJ Enhanced production of oxygen radicals in asthma. J Lab Clin Med 1994;123,131-136
MedlineWeb
of Science
66.
↵
Dohlman, AW,
Black, HR, Royall, JA Expired breath hydrogen peroxide is a marker of acute
airway inflammation in pediatric patients with asthma. Am Rev Respir Dis 1993;148,955-960
MedlineWeb
of Science
67.
↵
Stewart, RM,
Weir, EK, Montgomery, MR, et al Hydrogen peroxide contracts airway smooth
muscle: a possible endogenous mechanism. Respir Physiol1981;45,333-342
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
68.
↵
Nishida, Y,
Suzuki, S, Miyamoto, T Biphasic contraction of isolated guinea pig tracheal
chains by superoxide radical. Inflammation 1985;9,333-337
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
69.
↵
Barnes, PJ Reactive
oxygen species and airway inflammation. Free Radic Biol Med 1990;9,235-243
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
70.
↵
Wu, W,
Samoszuk, MK, Comhair, SA, et al Eosinophils generate brominating oxidants in
allergen-induced asthma. J Clin Invest2000;105,1455-1463
MedlineWeb
of Science
71.
↵
Day, RO,
Graham, GG, Whelton, A The position of paracetamol in the world of analgesics. Am J Ther 2000;7,51-54
Medline
72.
↵
Zimmerman,
HJ, Maddrey, WC Acetaminophen (paracetamol) hepatotoxicity with regular intake
of alcohol: analysis of instances of therapeutic misadventure. Hepatology 1995;22,767-773
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
73.
↵
Peterson, JD,
Herzenberg, LA, Vasquez, K, et al Glutathione levels in antigen-presenting
cells modulate Th1 versus Th2 response patterns. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 1998;95,3071-3076
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
74.
↵
Droge, W,
Breitkreutz, R Glutathione and immune function. Proc Nutr Soc2000;59,595-600
MedlineWeb
of Science
75.
↵
Bagnato, GF,
Gulli, S, De Pasquale, R, et al Effect of inhaled glutathione on airway
response to “Fog” challenge in asthmatic patients. Respiration1999;66,518-521
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
76.
↵
Varner, A
Paracetamol and asthma [letter]. Thorax 2000;55,882-883
CrossRefMedlineWeb
of Science
77.
↵
Probst, L,
Stoney, P, Jeney, E, et al Nasal polyps, bronchial asthma and aspirin
sensitivity. J Otolaryngol 1992;21,60-65
MedlineWeb
of Science
78.
↵
Mudge, D
Paracetamol and asthma. Thorax 2000;55,883-884
MedlineWeb
of Science
79.
↵
Davey, G,
Sedgwick, P, Maier, W, et al Association between migraine and asthma: matched
case-control study. Br J Gen Pract 2002;52,723-727
MedlineWeb
of Science
80.
↵
Chen, TC,
Leviton, A Asthma and eczema in children born to women with migraine. Arch Neurol 1990;47,1227-1230
Abstract/FREE Full
Text
81.
↵
USDA Food and Drug
Administration. Use caution with pain relievers, January-February 2003.
Available at: http://www.fda.gov/fdac/features/2003/103_pain.html. Accessed
January 20, 2005
82.
Lesko, SM,
Louik, C, Vezina, RM, et al Asthma morbidity after the short-term use of
ibuprofen in children. Pediatrics 2002;109,E20
CrossRefMedline
|