The Autoxidation of Human Red Cell Lipids
induced by Hydrogen Peroxide, 1971 http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1365-2141.1971.tb00790.x/abstract
Malonyldialdehyde
(MDA) formation, a measure of polyunsaturated fat autoxidation, was estimated
in normal human red cells incubated in
vitro. Exposure to
oxygen under a variety of conditions did not induce autoxidation. Exposure to
hydrogen peroxide was either by the addition of a hydrogen peroxide solution or
by incubation in an atmosphere saturated with hydrogen peroxide vapour. A
pattern of MDA formation was established with both methods…. A number of recognized
antioxidants
inhibited peroxide-induced MDA formation. Inhibition was proportional to the
logarithm of the antioxidant concentration.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
BIOLOGICAL
RANCIDIFICATION
Lancet 1969 Volume 294,
Issue 7622,
27 September 1969, Pages 684–688. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0140673669903900
Autoxidation, a
destructive interaction between unsaturated fats and molecular oxygen, accounts
for many industrial and natural-decay processes. The possibility that the body fats
might undergo a similar kind of
degradation is still largely ignored—perhaps because the irregular irreversible
pattern of this type of process seems at odds with the enzyme-controlled
reversible pathways of traditional biochemistry. Yet work with mitochondria and
other biological preparations has shown that the processes commonly grouped
together as " degeneration ", " fatigue ", and "
ageing " (none of which have a basis in classical enzymology) develop in
close parallel with evidence of rancidification.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Lipid peroxidation refers
to the oxidative degradation of lipids.
It is
the process in which free
radicals "steal" electrons from the lipids in cell
membranes,
resulting in cell damage. This process
proceeds by a free radical chain
reaction mechanism. It most often affects polyunsaturatedfatty
acids,
because they contain multiple double bonds in between which
lie methylene
bridges (-CH2-) that possess especially
reactive hydrogens.
As with any radical reaction, the reaction consists of
three major steps: initiation, propagation, and termination. Initiation is the
step in which a fatty acid radical is produced. The most notable initiators in
living cells are reactive
oxygen species (ROS), such as OH· and HO2,
which
combines with a hydrogen atom to make water and a fatty acid radical. The
fatty acid
radical is
not a very stable molecule, so it reacts readily with molecular oxygen,
thereby creating a peroxyl-fatty acid radical. This radical is also an unstable
species that reacts with another free fatty acid, producing a different fatty
acid radical and a lipid peroxide, or a cyclic peroxide if it had reacted with
itself. This cycle continues, as
the new fatty acid radical reacts in the same way.[1] The end products of lipid peroxidation are
reactive aldehydes, such as malondialdehyde (MDA) and 4-hydroxynonenal(HNE),
the second one being known also as
"second messenger of free radicals" and major bioactive marker of
lipid peroxidation, due to its numerous biological activities resembling
activities of reactive oxygen species. http://informahealthcare.com/toc/fra/44/10 In
addition, end-products of lipid peroxidation may be mutagenic and carcinogenic.[3] For instance, the end-product malondialdehyde reacts with deoxyadenosine and deoxyguanosine in DNA, forming DNA
adducts to them, primarily M1G.[3] Certain diagnostic tests are available for the
quantification of the end-products of lipid peroxidation, to be specific, malondialdehyde (MDA).[3] The most commonly used test is called a TBARS
Assay (thiobarbituric
acid reactive
substances assay). Thiobarbituric acid reacts with malondialdehyde to yield a
fluorescent product. However, there are other sources of malondialdehyde, so
this test is not completely specific for lipid peroxidation.[5] In recent years development of immunochemical
detection of HNE-histidine adducts opened more advanced methodological
possibilities for qualitative and quantitative detection of lipid peroxidation
in various human and animal tissues (http://informahealthcare.com/toc/fra/44/10)
as well as in body fluids, including human
serum and plasma samples (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3757688/). Wiki.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
http://informahealthcare.com/doi/full/10.3109/10715762.2010.498478
Pathological aspects of lipid peroxidation
October
2010, Vol. 44, No. 10 , Pages 1125-1171 (doi:10.3109/10715762.2010.498478)
Read More: http://informahealthcare.com/doi/full/10.3109/10715762.2010.498478 Lipid peroxidation in human diabetes: From the beginning to the
end (R Pamplona, J Serrano, J Boada, V Ayala, A Negre-Salvayre, R Salvayre, M
Portero-Otin)
Abstract
Lipid peroxidation (LPO)
product accumulation in human tissues is a major cause of tissular and cellular
dysfunction that plays a major role in ageing and most age-related and
oxidative stress-related diseases. The current evidence for the implication of
LPO in pathological processes is discussed in this review. New data and
literature review are provided evaluating the role of LPO in the
pathophysiology of ageing and classically oxidative stress-linked diseases,
such as neurodegenerative diseases, diabetes and atherosclerosis (the main
cause of cardiovascular complications). Striking evidences implicating LPO in
foetal vascular dysfunction occurring in pre-eclampsia, in renal and liver
diseases, as well as their role as cause and consequence to cancer development
are addressed.
The prevalence of diabetes mellitus (DM) will reach 300
million
in 20 years, in a close relationship with over-weight. This is mainly due to
consumption of high-energy diets unbalanced with physical activity. Both chronic
hyperglycaemia and
hyperglycaemic peaks during post-prandial periods constitute a factor for
increased oxidative stress in diabetes. In this short review we will depict
the evidences in human studies of the importance of lipid oxidation in the
development of diabetes from impaired fasting glucose up to DM chronic
complications.
Extracellular evidences of lipid peroxidation in human
diabetes. MDA levels are increased in T2DM patients
with complications compared with those non-complicated [280], a fact also present in comparison with non-DM individuals [281–284]. Besides, other aldehydes directly related to hyperglycaemia [285] as glyoxal and methylglyoxal, also increase in T1DM patients
as a very early event after hyperglycaemia [286,287]. Interaction between hyperglycaemia and lipid peroxidation
also includes the fact that MDA increases in
vivo modification by
glycation, as recently shown in chronic renal failure patients [288]. Other lipoxidation markers, as the isoketal F2-isoprostanes [289], oxidized cholesterol [290] and increased conjugated linolenic acid [291] also increase in DM patients. It has also been shown that
TBARS increase with the degree of metabolic impairment, from healthy patients
to T2DM in serum [292]. However, this later marker has been criticized in the context
of human diabetes, due to lack of specificity [287]. Furthermore, hyperglycaemia, before insulinization, leads to
increased lipid peroxidation in humans [293–295]. Recent data show that
HDL from T2DM patients is modified by lipid oxidation, in a niacine-preventable
fashion [296]. Similarly, T1DM patients exhibit elevated concentration of
spin-trapped alpha-phenyl-tert-butylnitrone adducts, measured by electron
paramagnetic resonance spectroscopic detection, as well as lipid-derived
oxygen-centred alkoxyl. This was accompanied by increased levels of lipid
hydroperoxides, with diminished levels of lycopene and retinol [297]. These findings are in accordance with those present in T2DM,
where the same adducts were increased, in the form of alkoxyl free radicals
derived from the peroxidation of lipid membranes [298]. Since direct spectroscopic evidences of lipid peroxidation
are correlated with lipid hydroperoxides, it is suggested that metal-induced
decomposition of those species are the precursors of alkoxyl radicals that are
thermodynamically able to further propagate oxidative damage to proteins.
In plasma, those lipids may arise from phospholipid moieties
belonging to either endothelial cells or erythrocytes, even from circulating
lipids. The implication of erythrocytes is sustained by increased MDA levels in
erythrocyte ghost membranes of T1DM, when compared with euglycemic individuals
[283]. In line with this, pioneering work of Jain and colleagues [299,300] led to the identification of lipid peroxidation
as an important factor increasing erythrocyte fragility in human diabetes with
a good correlation with glycaemic control.
The initiation agent in the absence of mitochondrial activities
(i.e. in plasma) should be the superoxide resulting from glucose and glycation
products decomposition [301], in accordance to pioneering work by Hunt et al. [302]. This work evidenced an increase in hydroxyl radicals in the
presence of glucose (at concentrations present in human diabetes), in a process
termed glucose auto-oxidation. This process, even in non-diabetic states, may
contribute to the increased lipoxidative stress evidenced during oral glucose
tolerance tests [303]. In accordance with this, T1DM patients show increases in
plasma MDA levels after standardized meals [304]. Not only do diabetes patients show increased lipoxidation: it
has been demonstrated that MDA and F2-isoprostanes in plasma correlate with
glycaemic indexes of meals, suggesting that even in euglycaemia post-pandrial
increases in oxidative stress lead to increased lipid peroxidation [298,305].
Besides nutritional supplementation, also correcting in
some
instances lipid peroxidation, treatment aimed at tackling basic mechanisms of
chronic diabetes complications, such as aldose reductase pathway, also show
some effect in lipid peroxidation. Thus, the use of an inhibitor of aldose
reductase could specifically reduce lipid hydroperoxides in erythrocytes in
T2DM patients after 3 months of treatment. This reinforces the concept of an
adequate choice for an indicator of lipid peroxidation damage, as other
markers, such as plasma TBARS, MDA-modified LDL or even vitamin E were not
affected by this treatments [306].
In all these evidences reported for human subjects, it
is demonstrated
that in a close relationship with glycaemic control, both T1DM and T2DM leads
to increased extracellular lipid peroxidation, potentially contributing to
their development and complications. Besides obvious solutions, as
insulinization, nutritional and advanced pharmacological therapies could also improve
lipoxidative status, aimed at preventing long-term complications of DM.
Intracellular evidences of lipid peroxidation in diabetes:
The
skeletal muscle case and involvement in insulin resistance. Since the key works led by Brownlee and
colleagues [307–309] in which oxidative stress was identified as an unifying
mechanism behind other recognized pathways between hyperglycaemia and chronic
complications in endothelial cells, several other works have extended this
concept to other cells and tissues. High glucose levels, in T2DM high fatty
acid content in muscle cells, are associated both as a cause and/or a consequence
of mitochondrial function [310]. As a cause, in humans, even a short consumption of high-fat
diets led to increases in intracellular lipids in skeletal muscles in healthy
individuals [311]. Also, in individuals with relatives suffering of T2DM, a
small reduction in mitochondrial function is accompanied by an unexpectedly
high accumulation in intracellular lipid contents [312,313]. As a consequence, lipids would induce
impairment of mitochondrial function. In T2DM patients, plasma FFA levels are
significantly and negatively correlated with mitochondrial function, leading to
impaired ATP production [314]. Thus, diminished PGC1a levels—a key regulator of energy
metabolism—in insulin resistant individuals could be induced by accumulation of
intramuscular lipids [315,316].
Mitochondrial ROS (mitROS) can rapidly react with mitochondrial
DNA, protein and lipids, thereby leading to oxidative damage. As an example, in
skeletal muscle, the fatty acids present in excessive amounts in T2DM patients
can be very prone to ROS-induced oxidative damage, resulting in the formation
of lipid peroxides. Especially accumulation of fatty acids in the inner
mitochondrial membrane of mitochondria, at the site where ROS are formed, would
be susceptible to peroxidation, subsequently inducing oxidative damage to the
mitochondrial machinery. In this line, it should be remarked that the
percentage of total electron flow directed to free radical generation in
mitochondria is not constant in different tissues and different conditions
inside a given tissue, which suggests that mitROS generation is more than a
simple byproduct of mitochondrial respiration, as frequently assumed, and
should be better viewed as a homeostatically controlled variable. Oxygen
radical generation at the respiratory chain has been classically attributed to
complex III semiquinone [317] and complex I flavin mononucleotide [318,319] or complex I FeS clusters near the rotenone-binding site [320]. Besides those structural characteristics, adaptable variables
such as entry of substrates could also play a key role in determining mitROS
production. Thus, β-oxidation controls entry of fatty acids into mitochondria,
although this system does not prevent completely the interaction of fats with
mitochondria and hence its contact with mitROS sources. This is due to the fact
that physical interaction, via ‘flip-flop’ mechanism, could allow matrix
membrane entry of excess of fatty acids [321]. Since in this location they cannot enter energy production
due to the absence of acyl-CoA synthetase, they remain into the inner
mitochondrial membrane, exposed to mitROS. Alternatively, and analogously with
the mitochondrial changes induced by high glucose concentrations, increased
fatty acid efflux to mitochondria could directly increase mitROS production,
more glucose being oxidized in the TCA cycle. This situation drives one to push
more electron donors (NADH and FADH2) into the electron transport chain, thus
leading to an increase in ROS generation [307]. In this situation, there is a higher degree of reduction of
complexes I and III, increasing their rate of ROS production. Likewise, in the
insulin resistance syndrome, there is an increased free fatty acids flux from
adipocytes into arterial endothelial cells that would result in increased fatty
acid oxidation by mitochondria [322,323]. Since both β-oxidation of fatty acids and oxidation of fatty
acid-derived acetyl CoA by the TCA cycle generate the same electron donors
(NADH and FADH2) generated by glucose oxidation, increased FFA oxidation may
cause mitochondrial over-production of ROS by the mechanism above described for
hyperglycaemia.
The mechanism notwithstanding, muscle cells from obese
pre-diabetic patients show increased intramyocellular lipid peroxidation [324]. As in ageing, where high lipid peroxidation is associated to
lower lifespan by increased oxidation-derived damage to proteins and nucleic
acids [325], it is suggested that lipid peroxidation in mitochondria from
insulin resistant individuals could lead to mitochondrial function impairment [310], thereby generating a vicious circle. In accordance with this,
high fat diets induced increased mitROS production [326].
Losing to win: Uncoupling mechanisms for mitROS control
in DM. Mitochondrial uncoupling through proton
leakage has been proposed as a mechanism to lower mitROS. This is especially
interesting as the relationship between proton gradient and mitROS is
exponential, so a small loss in ATP production could have a high trade-off
value [327]. In human ageing, this mild mitochondrial uncoupling could
explain why some muscles show more age-related losses than others [328].
As known since the early 1960s, fatty acids are capable
to
induce mitochondrial uncoupling [329]. Our previous data show that a homeostatic mechanism depending
on lipid peroxidation controls mitROS production through mild uncoupling. Thus,
increased mitROS production generates 4-HNE, which, besides a signalling role,
shows also both a propagation role and also an uncoupling role, leading to
diminished mitROS production [330]. In T2DM, though speculatively, this mechanism would be
overwhelmed, as increased lipid peroxidation derived protein damage has been
evidenced in samples from animal models of this disease [331]. Furthermore, expression of uncoupling proteins leads to both
diminished lipid peroxidation [332] and lipid peroxidation-derived damage: in mitochondria from
UCP3-under-expressing models significantly higher levels of lipoxidative damage
than wild-type controls were found, suggesting that UCP3 functions in vivo as part
of the antioxidant defences of
the cell [333], a finding also observed by other authors [334]. Noteworthy, T2DM patients and insulin-resistant individuals
show a diminished value of UCP3 protein levels in muscle, suggesting that an
impairment in the expression of this protein and, possibly, other mitochondrial
mechanisms for mitROS normalization could underlie mitochondrial dysfunction in
insulin-resistant and diabetic states [316,335].
In conclusion, these data reveal that
not only extracellular
lipid peroxidation is important for chronic complications, but also
intracellular lipid peroxidation could be a key factor in the relationship
between unbalanced energy homeostasis and T2 DM rising incidence.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
http://ajpendo.physiology.org/content/299/6/E879.short
Protective and
detrimental effects of 4-hydroxyalkenals in diabetes
Y. Riahi, G Cohen, O Shamni, S
Sasson
The peroxidation of polyunsaturated fatty acids is intensified
in diabetes. The
peroxidation of n-3 and n-6 polyunsaturated fatty acids and the production of
4-hydroxyalkenals are intensified in diabetes due to the pro-oxidative
environment induced by prolonged hyperglycaemia [336]. Of particular interest are the peroxidation products of n-6
poly-unsaturated fatty acids, namely 4-HNE and 4-HDDE [67,70,337]. The former is the peroxidation product of
15-hydroperoxyeicosatetraenoic acid (15-HpETE) and
13-hydroperoxyoctadecadienoic acid (13-HpODE), which are 15-lipoxygenase
(15-LO) metabolites of arachidonic- and linoleic acid, respectively. 4-HDDE is
the peroxidation product of 12-hydroperoxyeicosatetraenoic (12-HpETE), the
12-LO metabolite of arachidonic acid [337,338].
The physiological, pathophysiological or cytotoxic effects
of
4-hydroxyalkenals depend on their absolute concentrations. The best example is
4-HNE: Esterbauer et al. [67] showed that at concentrations higher than 20 μmol/L it
exhibited cytotoxic effects that result from its chemical reactivity and the formation
of stable adducts with proteins and nucleic acids, which alter their functions
[70]. Bacot et al. [337,339] demonstrated that 4-hydroxyalkenal-induced
membrane disorders resulted from the formation of adducts with ethanolamine
phospholipids. They also reported that the potency of 4-HDDE in forming such
ethanolamine phospholipids-adducts was ∼ 3-fold
higher than that of 4-HNE [337,338]. Likewise, we found that 4-HDDE induced
vascular endothelial cell (VEC) death at significantly lower concentrations
than 4-HNE (1 vs 25 µmol/L, respectively) [340]. The higher chemical reactivity of 4-HDDE is attributed to the
presence of two double bonds and its higher hydrophobicity in comparison with
4-HNE (Log p-values 3.48
and 2.45, respectively) [339].
Normally, the cellular levels of 4-hydroxyalkenals are
well-controlled because their precursors, 12- and 15-HpETEs, are effectively reduced
by GPx to the corresponding hydroxyl-derivatives 12- or
15-hydroxyeicosatetraenoic acid (12-HETE and 15-HETE) [336]. However, free radicals can slow and even block this pathway
by inactivating GPx [337]. This leads to the accumulation of HpETEs, which are then subjected
to the free radical-initiated peroxidation process that ends in the generation
of 4-HDDE and 4-HNE. Similarly, 13-HpODE is peroxidized to generate 4-HNE.
SEVERAL alternative mechanisms for the peroxidation process and the generation
of these reactive aldehydes have been proposed [4,341–346]. Common to these models is the
primary hydroxyl radical-induced abstraction of hydrogen atom from 12- and
15-HpETE. The resulting radicals interact with free oxygen and further undergo
a chain-breaking reaction to generate the corresponding 4-hydroxyalkenals.
Figure 2 depicts the two main routes of arachidonic
acid transformation: the common pathway that occurs in metabolically
undisturbed cells and the aberrant peroxidation pathway that is induced by an
excessive oxidative stress. This model suggests that tissue-specific production
of 4-hydroxyalkenals correlates with the specific pattern of expression of
lipoxygenases and the biosynthesis of the corresponding HpETEs. This has been
demonstrated by Guichardant’s group [337,347] in diabetic rat's retina that expresses
15-LO and generate 4-HNE, but not 4-HDDE. Similarly, Coleman et al. [348] have found that 4-HNE, generated from 15-HpETE, is the major
peroxidation product in 3T3-L1 pre-adipocytes. We have found that bovine aortic
endothelial cells that express 12-LO generate under hyperglycaemic conditions
excessive levels of 4-HDDE, but not 4-HNE [340,349,350]. It is reasonable to suggest that human VEC that also
predominantly over-express 12-LO under high glucose conditions preferentially
generate 4-HDDE under such conditions [351]. A similar relationship between 12-HpETE and 15-HpETE and the
generation of the corresponding 4-HDDE and 4-HNE has been reported by Bacot et
al. [337]. We speculate that 4-HDDE is the putative lipid peroxidation
product that Bleich et al. [352] have implicated in β-cell dysfunction following
cytokine-mediated increased expression of 12-LO. This model also shows that
oxidative stress induced by hyperglycaemia diverts the flux of HpETEs from the
enzymatic pathway towards the peroxidative arm. This role of free radicals in
lipid peroxidation has been demonstrated in several systems [347,353–355].
In addition, hyperglycaemia increases the expression and
cellular level of 12- and 15-LO in cells and subsequently the availability of
HpETEs to peroxidation. Such induction of 12-LO was discovered in islets of
Langerhans from Zucker diabetic fatty rats (a rodent model of T2DM) in
comparison with the non-diabetic controls [356] and in islets isolated from others types of diabetic rats [357]. We investigated the pattern of expression of 12-LO in primary
cultures of aortic endothelial and smooth muscle cells and discovered that high
glucose levels increased the cell content of 12-LO (but not 15-LO) [340,349,350]. Similarly, Natarajan et al. [358] reported that elevated glucose levels increased the expression
of 12-LO in porcine aortic SMC.
These findings suggest that the impact of hyperglycaemia
on
lipid peroxidation is synergetic: the expression of lipoxygenases is elevated
in cells and the products of these enzymes are channelled to peroxidation and
an augmented formation of 4-hydroxyalkenals. This model predicts an increased abundance
of 4-hydroxyalkenals in diabetic individuals. Indeed, Toyokuni et al. [359] found a marked increase in the level of 4-HNE-modified albumin
in sera of T2DM patients in comparison with normoglycaemic subjects. These
elevated levels were attributed to an increased generation of 4-HNE in
peripheral tissues. Similar observations were made in Zucker obese rats [360]. Hitherto, no such determinations of 4-HDDE and 4-HDDE-protein
adducts in diabetic patients have been reported. Nevertheless, Guichardant et
al. [347] measured significant amounts of 4-HDDE metabolites along with
4-HNE and 4-HHE metabolites in urine samples of healthy individuals.
Roles of 4-hydroxyalkenals in diabetes. Products of lipid peroxidation can affect
cells in diabetic subjects in two major ways, depending on their concentrations
in cells and organs. First, high levels of 4-hydroxyalkenals induce detrimental
effects and substantial cell damage that lead to severe complications of
diabetes. Second, intermediate non-toxic concentrations of these compounds may
attenuate cellular signalling and metabolic pathways, which may be either
unfavourable or protective.
Role of 4-hydroxyalkenals in β-cell dysfunction. The tendency of
4-hydroxyalkenals to bind covalently to amino acid moieties (i.e. histidine,
lysine, cysteine) in proteins, guanine nucleotides in DNA and phospholipids
underlies their significant contribution to the development of complications of
diabetes. Foremost, the failure of pancreatic β-cells to adequately increase
insulin secretion in response to hyperglycaemia is considered, together with
peripheral insulin resistance, a critical factor in the development of T2DM.
Hyperglycaemia-induced free radical formation is a major contributing factor to
the deterioration of β-cell in T2DM. Various studies have alluded to a
detrimental role of 4-hydroxyalkenals in this process: Bleich et al. [361] linked the increased expression of 12-LO in islets of diabetic
rats to impaired insulin secretory function. Prasad et al. [362] found that over-expression of 12-LO in cultured INS-1E β-cells
halved their glucose-induced insulin secretory capacity. Similarly, the
incubation of isolated rat islets with a high level of 4-HNE (100 µM)
significantly lowered their insulin secretory capacity [363]. Conversely, 12-LO knockout mice did not develop glucose
intolerance and β-cell dysfunction when fed a diabetogenic high fat diet [364]. In addition, such 12-LO knockout mice were highly resistant
to streptozotocin-induced diabetes and their isolated islets maintained good
insulin secretory capacity following treatment with inflammatory cytokines.
Collectively, these finding suggest that 12-HpETE, the immediate product of
12-LO, and its peroxidation products adversely affect β-cell function [352]. This idea was confirmed when over-expression of 12-LO in
cultured INS-1E β-cells abrogated glucose-induced insulin secretion [362]. Further support comes from the finding that β-cell death in
rodent and human islets exposed in
vitro to inflammatory
cytokines (i.e. IL-1β, INFγ, TNFα) was prevented in the presence of baicalein,
a specific inhibitor of 12-LO, whereas incubation of the cells with 12-LO
metabolites reduced basal insulin secretion and increased cell death [365]. It has been suggested that 4-HNE at non-toxic concentrations
inhibits cell growth and induces accumulation of cells in the G0/G1 phase of
the cell cycle [366]. Plausibly, a similar inhibitory effect of 4-HNE on β-cells
replications may reduce their mass in islets, a phenomenon characteristic to
diabetic islets.
The autoimmune and cytokine-mediated destruction of β-cells
in
Type-1 diabetes has also been associated with over-production of reactive
aldehydes, such as 4-HNE. The non-obese diabetic (NOD) mice usually develop
severe autoimmune insulitis and diabetes. However, the expression of an
inactive 12/15-LO in these mice rendered them resistant to the development of
diabetes [367]. Similarly, Bleich et al. [352] found that islets isolated from 12-LO knockout mice were
resistant to cytokine-induced damage. Suarez-Pinzon et al. [368] also identified a key role for 4-HNE and other cytotoxic
aldehydes in the destruction of rat pancreatic islet β-cells by cytokines.
Other β-cell lines (RINm5F and HIT-T15) were particularly susceptible to 4-HNE,
which caused 75–100% cell death at 50 µM [369]. It was suggested that 4-HNE and other lipid peroxidation
products induce apoptosis in RINm5F cells [370]. Noteworthy, not all cells are equally susceptible to
4-hydroxyalkenal-induced damage due to a variable expression of the major
detoxifying enzymes glutathione S-transferase (GST, i.e. Gst-µ3 and Gst-ω1) and
fatty aldehyde dehydrogenase (FALDH, i.e. Aldh3a1) [348]. GSTs detoxify 4-hydroxyalkenals through conjugative reactions,
while FALDH transforms the aldehyde group into a carboxylic moiety to produce
4-hydroxy-2E,6Z-dodecadienoic acid (4-HDDA) from 4-HDDE and 4-hydroxy-2E-nonenoic
acid (4-HNA) from 4-HNE. Both 4-HNA and 4-HDDA were identified in human urine [347] and in various cells and tissues [67,371]. Only few studies addressed the
possibility that these metabolites are biologically active. Murphy et al. [372] reported that 4-HNA bound to the γ-butyrate receptor in the
CNS, while Echtay et al. [330] suggested that it uncoupled proton conductance in
mitochondria. The susceptibility of β-cells to oxidative stress- and
ROS-induced damages has been attributed to their inherent poor intrinsic
antioxidant defence [373–376]. This, coupled to a progressive 4-hydroxyalkenal-induced inactivation
of FALDH and GST, may exaggerate β-cell dysfunction. Of interest is also the
report on an impaired hepatic disposal of 4-HNE in diabetic rats [377]. Consequently, the slow clearance may extend the exposure of
β-cells to 4-hydroxyalkenals and further intensify β-cell dysfunction.
Role of 4-hydroxyalkenals in macrovascular
diseases. Hyperglycaemia is an established major
and independent risk factor in the development of cardiovascular disease in
diabetes [378–381]. Endothelial cell dysfunction is the earliest event in the
development of atherosclerotic lesions in blood vessels. This condition may
result from a direct oxidative damage and over-production of 4-hydroxyalkenals
that compromise the integrity and functions of the endothelial cell monolayer.
For instance, Minekura et al. [382] found that 4-HNE significantly reduced the expression of
adhesion molecules (i.e. ICAM-1, VCAM-1) induced by TNF-α and NF-κB activation
in primary cultures of human aortic endothelial cells. Tetrahydrobiopterin
(THB), the cofactor of endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS), is
particularly susceptible to inactivating interactions with 4-HNE. The
inactivation and lack of THB induce uncoupling of the enzymatic reaction of
eNOS, which leads to the generation of superoxide radicals that further
exacerbate the oxidative damage [383]. Interestingly, 4-HNE has been implicated in macrophage
activation and their transformation to foam cells in diabetic blood vessels [5]. This is partly due to the 4-HNE capacity to increase the
expression of class A scavenger receptors, which enhances macrophage foam cell
formation [384]. Moreover, oxLDL has a considerable capacity to covalently
bind 4-HNE [385].
View
larger version(18K)
|
Figure 2. Mechanism of 4-hydroxyalkenal generation.
The enzymes 12- and 15-lipoxygenase (12- and 15-LO) metabolize arachidonic
acid to the corresponding hydroperoxyeicosatetraenoic acids (12- and
15-HpETE), which are further converted by glutathione peroxidase (GPx) to
12- or 15-hyroxyeicostetraenoic acid (12- and 15-HETE). Radical induced
inactivation of GPx diverts 12- and 15-HpETE to the peroxidation pathway to
ultimately generate the respective 4-hydoxdodecadienal (4-HDDE) and
4-hdroxynonenal (4-HNE).
|
|
The smooth muscle cell layer in blood vessels is also a target
for 4-HNE, which induces a marked mitogenic response, characteristic to the
early event in atherosclerosis [386–388]. High levels of 4-HNE were associated with other effects in
smooth muscle cells, such as apoptosis [389], autophagy [390], cytotoxicity [391], production of TGF-β [392], impaired PDGF receptor activity [393] and enhanced matrix metalloproteinase-2 production [394,395].
The physiological relevance of these in
vitro studies has been corroborated by
Yamanouchi et al. [396], who studied streptozotocin-diabetic APA Syrian hamsters that
developed atheromatous lesions. Immunohistochemical analysis of foam cells in
the fatty streaks in blood vessels showed a significant increased abundance of
4-HNE-protein adducts. Similarly, Meng et al. [397] found a high content of 4-HNE-protein adducts in aortae of
streptozotocin (STZ)-diabetic rats. Recently, Mattson [53] suggested in a comprehensive review a central role of 4-HNE in
obesity, in the metabolic syndrome and in vascular and neurodegenerative
disorders. Of particular interest in this review is the suggestion to use 4-HNE
as a target to prevent and treat the metabolic syndrome and associated
diseases. Two main st rategies were put forward: to reduce 4-HNE production by
suppressing lipid peroxidation or by its detoxification.
Other complications
The aetiology of other peripheral complications in diabetes
has
also been linked to aberrant interactions of 4-HNE. For example, Polak and
Zagorski [398] found significantly higher levels of 4-HNE and MDA in diabetic
patients with retinopathy in comparison with patients that did not develop this
complication. The presence of AGEs and 4-HNE-protein adducts was evidenced
immunohistochemically in the glomerulus in diabetic nephropathy in humans [399,400]. Others found that 4-HNE mimicked
features of diabetic neuropathy by inducing mitochondrial dysfunction and
aberrant axonal outgrowth in adult sensory neurons isolated form rats [401,402]. It has been shown that effective
quenching of 4-HNE can greatly improve the wound healing process, which is a
serious complication in diabetes [403].
Non-toxic interactions of 4-hydroxyalkenals
in diabetes. Unfavourable
interactions: By their tendency to form covalent bonds with various amino
acid moieties, 4-hydroxyalkenals can modify structures of proteins even at
non-toxic levels and alter their function. Several reports have addressed such
interactions of 4-HNE that affect signalling pathways in cells [404–406]. Some interactions have been associated with cell
differentiation, transcription factors regulation, activation of stress
kinases, mitogenic response, stimulation of heat shock proteins or modulation
of transduction mechanisms. Demozay et al. [407] have demonstrated the role of 4-HNE in attenuating the insulin
transduction mechanism and inducing insulin resistance in 3T3-LI adipocytes.
Incubation of these cells with non-toxic concentrations of HNE significantly
decreased the level of the insulin receptor substrate (IRS)-1/2 proteins. This
led to a down-regulated response of downstream targets of the insulin
transduction pathway, leading to insulin resistance. The underlying mechanism
was the formation of 4-HNE-IRS protein adducts and their rapid degradation.
Grimsrud et al. [408] performed a thorough LC-ESI MS/MS analysis of proteins from
epididymal adipose tissue of diabetic mice and identified a number of
regulatory proteins that bound 4-HNE that were linked to oxidative stress
responses and the development of insulin resistance.
Glucose transporters are also targets for 4-HNE. Reagan
et al. [409] found an increased level of 4-HNE conjugation with glucose
transporter-3 (GLUT-3) in the hippocampus of diabetic rats and linked it to
decreased hippocampal neural glucose utilization. It is not clear whether 4-HNE
similarly interacts with the ubiquitous GLUT-1, the hepatic and β-cell specific
GLUT-2 or the insulin-sensitive GLUT-4.
Protective interactions: We have
discovered that VEC exposed to high glucose levels can
reduce the rate of glucose uptake and prevent adverse effects associated with
an increased influx of glucose. Specifically, these cells reduced the cellular
level of their principal glucose transporter GLUT-1 mRNA and protein, as well
as its plasma membrane content [349,350,410]. High glucose also increased the expression of 12-LO and the
production of 12-HpETE and 12-HETE. Pharmacological inhibition of 12-LO
completely blocked these high glucose-induced down-regulatory effects [349–351]. The reduced expression of GLUT-1 in VEC exposed to high
glucose resulted from post-transcriptional destabilization and degradation of
GLUT-1 mRNA. The protein calreticulin, which was also over-expressed under high
glucose conditions, bound to a specific 10-nucleotide sequence in the 3′-UTR of
GLUT-1 mRNA, destabilized the molecule and rendered it susceptible to nuclease
digestion [411]. We also discovered that the expression of calreticulin was
augmented in blood vessels of diabetic animals [411]. Collectively, our studies suggest a functional link between
12-LO and its metabolites to GLUT-1 mRNA destabilization by calreticulin.
We have recently found [340] that the augmented expression of 12-LO in VEC under high
glucose conditions was accompanied with a marked increase in the generation and
secretion of 4-HDDE, but not 4-HNE. Moreover, using pharmacological and
molecular approaches we proved that 4-HDDE was an endogenous ligand of the
Peroxisome Proliferator-Activated Receptor (PPAR)-δ in these cells. When added
to cells at non-toxic concentrations (50 nM) 4-HDDE activated PPARδ, which
specifically interacted with a PPAR-response element in the calreticulin gene
and augmented its expression. Previous studies have shown that PPARδ
preferentially interacts with unsaturated fatty acids and eicosanoids [406,412]. X-ray analyses of crystal structures of
the PPARδ ligand binding domain (LBD) identified a network of hydrogen bonds
with His413, Tyr427, His287 and Thr253 involved
in the interaction with
eicosapentanoic acid [413]. Interestingly, His413 has also been implicated in a
hydrogen-bonding interaction with the 4-hydroxy group of 4-HNE [348]. The sites involved in 4-HDDE interaction with the LBD of
PPARδ have not been identified yet. This natural protective mechanism against
the deleterious effects of hyperglycaemia in vascular cells may explain why
some diabetic patients never develop cardiovascular complications, as was found
in the Adult Treatment Panel III trial [414]. Figure 3 depicts our working hypothesis: patients
who moderately increase the generation of 4-HDDE in VEC under hyperglycaemic
conditions benefit from its protective interaction with PPARδ and the
subsequent reduction in GLUT-1 levels. When 4-HDDE production is not
controlled, it adversely interacts with proteins, DNA and phospholipid and
causes substantial damage to the cells. Theoretically, low levels of
4-hydroxyalkenals in VEC may result from a moderate increase in 12/15- LO
expression and/or an efficient neutralization of 4-hydroxyalkenals.
_
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
The role of oxidative stress is very important in different
liver diseases, mainly in alcoholic and non-alcoholic steatohepatitis and liver
cirrhosis, furthermore in chronic viral hepatitis, especially in chronic
hepatitis C as well as in primary hepatocellular cancer (HCC). The main
processes producing free radicals in mammals are the following: mitochondrial
oxidative metabolism providing energy supply, microsomal drug-metabolizing
enzyme system, biosynthesis of prostaglandins, constitutive and inducible NO-synthase
activity, free radical-producing reactions of phagocytes, monocytes,
macrophages and Kupffer's cells and auto-oxidation of H2O2 produced in peroxisomes.
Another
consequence of free radical activity is lipid peroxidation [445]. In the mechanism of oxidative stress and also in its
biological consequences, free radicals can attack small molecules containing
thiol and amine groups as well as macromolecules building up the cells. Due to
peroxidative damage of the lipids in the cell membrane, permeability changes
may occur. Nucleic acid injury can lead to mutations and neoplastic processes
of the cells.
The healthy
organism is
able to prevent the over-production of free radicals. Low oxygen tension of the
tissues is a basic condition. Its value is ∼ 26 mmHg or less. The primary line of
antioxidants consists of representatives of the enzymatic defence. It is
supplemented by antioxidant vitamins with scavenger property (vitamins C, A, E,
K), the cofactors, compounds containing thiol, phosphor, amine, polyamine,
phenols, quinolines, ubiquinone (coenzyme Q), flavonoids, polyenes, glucose,
urate, bilirubin, etc.
Non-alcoholic steatohepatitis
and liver cirrhosis
Non-alcoholic fatty liver (NAFLD) is a multi-factorial
liver
disease. It includes a wide spectrum of liver damage characterized by
histological changes of alcoholic origin (ranging from uncomplicated fatty
liver to steatohepatitis, fibrosis and cirrhosis) in non-alcoholics (< 20
g/day ethanol consumption). The non-alcoholic
steatohepatitis (NASH) is
part of this disease spectrum, which can progress to hepatic cirrhosis and liver
failure. Its primary forms
have been proposed to be a manifestation or consequence of the metabolic
syndrome, closely related to insulin resistance. It can be caused by several
other metabolic factors and viral infections, like hepatitis C. The history of
non-alcoholic fatty liver disease is not always benign, sometimes it can be
accompanied by hepatocellular carcinoma [446].
Researches have identified the factors that can play a
causative
role: oxidative stress, lipid peroxidation, abnormal cytokine production, fatty
acid metabolic disturbance and insulin resistance. The pathophysiology of
non-alcoholic fatty liver involves insulin resistance and production of
reactive oxygen species, which stimulate the synthesis of several cytokines (Figure 11) through the up-regulation of their transcription by nuclear
factor-κB (NF-κB). The combination of these events causes hepatocyte injury via
direct oxidative injury, TNF-α induced apoptosis or inflammation [447].
Role of free fatty acids and insulin resistance. Free fatty acids (FFA) have a decisive
role in the development of insulin resistance by being transformed into
acyl-CoA intracellularly. In addition to free fatty acids, TNFα and
hyperinsulinaemia also play a role in the activation of one of the mechanisms
responsible for the negative control of signal transduction of insulin—namely
the Ser/Thr-phosphorylation of insulin receptor and insulin-receptor-substrate
(IRS) protein—that blocks the signal transduction processes of insulin. In this
way muscle cells, hepatocytes and adipocytes all become resistant to insulin.
The activity of mitochondrial respiratory chain complexes is reduced in
patients with NASH, showing a positive correlation with TNFα levels, insulin
resistance (IR) and body mass index (BMI) values.
Inherited defects in the mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation
are supposed to exist in the offspring (diagnosed with IR) of patients with
T2DM, leading to disorders in the intramyocellular fatty acid metabolism. The
genes dependent on nuclear respiratory factor-1 (NRF-1) that code enzymes, that
play crucial roles in the oxidative metabolism and mitochondrial function, are
expressed to a lesser extent in diabetes mellitus and IR, possibly due to the
reduction of PGC1-expression (PPAR-γ co-activator 1-β and 1-α). In the
metabolic syndrome, FFA are released from the abnormal mesenteric tissue to a
certain extent depending on the ratio of the β-3- and α-2 receptors in the
given fat tissue, as β-3-adrenoreceptors and α-2-receptors are responsible for
the induction and the inhibition of the lipolytic process, respectively.
Polymorphism of the β-3-receptor has been connected with IR and visceral
obesity for a long time, most recently with NAFLD. IR is of decisive importance
in how NASH is expressed in a patient, especially in the presence of a reduced
mitochondrial oxidation. According to recent research, this involves increased
lipolysis in the peripheral tissues, an increase in fatty acid uptake by the
hepatocytes, the β-oxidation of the fatty acids taken up by the hepatocytes
increases, and the uptake of lipoprotein by the tissues is reduced, due to
insufficient lipoprotein lipase. IR is much more severe in patients with NASH
than in those diagnosed with ‘simple’ fatty liver.
Mitochondrial dysfunction in NAFLD. Mitochondrial abnormalities are closely
related to the pathogenesis of NAFLD, which raised the possibility that NAFLD
is a mitochondrial disease [448]. Many genes encoding mitochondrial proteins in skeletal muscle
and fat are negatively correlated with body mass, mtDNA depletion in
hepatocytes impairs mitochondrial function and causes hepatic steatosis and
other liver injuries. Multiple enzymes are involved in mitochondrial
β-oxidation and their deficiency may lead to the development of hepatic
steatosis.
A number of mechanisms can be considered to explain the
mitochondrial dysfunction found in NAFLD patients and animal models. Possible
mechanisms include (a) excessive ROS production, (b) increased TNFα expression
and (c) altered PGC-1 expression. MRC dysfunction can directly lead to the
production of ROS. If electron flow is interrupted at any point in the
respiratory chain, the preceding respiratory intermediates can transfer
electrons to molecular oxygen to produce superoxide anion and H2O2.
MDA and 4-HNE can inhibit mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase by forming adducts
with this
enzyme. ROS-induced depletion in mtDNA can severely lower mitochondrial number
and function, leading to steatosis and liver lesions. Mitochondrial dysfunction
may not only cause fat accumulation, but also may generate ROS and cytokines,
contributing to the progression of NAFLD by inducing hepatic inflammation and
fibrosis [448].
Non-organ-specific autoantibodies (NOSA);
positive fatty liver.
Non-organ specific autoantibodies (NOSA) include anti-nuclear antibodies (ANA),
smooth muscle antibodies (SMA) and anti-mitochondrial antibodies (AMA). They
occur in a variety of non-autoimmune chronic liver disease. Their production
could be secondary to or triggered by hepatocellular inflammation and necrosis.
NOSA positivity in NAFLD has been found to be more prevalent compared to the
general population. We have studied the prevalence of non-organ-specific
autoantibodies and their correlates with cytokine release and free
radical-antioxidant balance in non-alcoholic fatty liver disease [449]. Prevalence of NOSA positivity was found to be 55% in our
NAFLD patients. Autoantibody positive patients showed lower antioxidant
capacity: lower SH-group concentration, decreased total antioxidant status and
elevated chemiluminescence intensity. We suppose that, similar to alcoholic
liver disease, the aldehyde products of lipid peroxidation, such as MDA, can
react with proteins and form stable protein adducts, which are very immunogenic
and capable of inducing immune response, resulting in generation of antibodies.
NAFLD with autoantibody positivity may have a worse prognosis because of the
impaired antioxidant status. It can be supposed that the appearance of
autoantibodies in NAFLD is triggered by free radical reaction, but further
investigations are needed to understand the significance, role and the exact
mechanisms of NOSA production in NAFLD [449].
Fatty liver in childhood
According to studies, the idiopathic
steatohepatitis is characteristic
mostly of obese children of peripubertal age. The development of fatty liver
can be attributed to several factors. Pathogenetic causes of lipid accumulation
in the hepatocytes—likely in adults—may include (1) reduced oxidation and
expenditure of fatty acids; (2) increased synthesis of fatty acids; (3) reduced
release of triglycerides from the liver; and (4) increased release of fatty
acids from the peripheral fat depots [6]. The pathomechanism has a characteristic two-step form: at
first fat is accumulated in the liver cells and then this induces a fibrous
reaction. Accumulation of ROS has an important role in both steps. Probably the
FFA reaching mitochondria cause saturation of mitochondrial beta-oxidation,
creating ROS and lipid peroxides, as well as they activate the CYP2E1 isoform
of cytochrome P450 enzyme in hepatocytes and Kupffer cells. Children with NAFLD
or NASH have an increased disposition to cardiovascular complications,
hyperlipidemia and insulin resistance—or, in the case of alcohol consumption,
to alcoholic liver disease—in adulthood. The principal treatment in obese
children consists of a diet which is low in fat and poor in refined
carbohydrates, as well as physical exercise of medium intensity. Blood glucose
and lipid levels should be monitored during the treatment [450].
Fatty liver and hepatitis C
viral infection
The significance of fatty liver alteration in the hepatitis
C
virus (HCV) infection [451] is important because of the decreased viral response to the
antiviral drug therapy in these cases. Among patients with HCV genotype 1
infection, the grade of steatosis was correlated with host-related factors,
mainly with the presence of the metabolic syndrome. In genotype 3, steatosis
degree correlates with liver HCV quantification and serum viral load. In
genotype 1, steatosis depends on leptin levels and insulin resistance.
Insulin resistance and hyperinsulinaemia have been found
in
association with liver fibrosis in hepatitis C [451]. The mechanisms through which insulin resistance promotes
fibrosis progression include: oxidative stress, lipid peroxidation, fat
accumulation in the hepatocytes, hyperleptinaemia, increased TNFα production
and impaired expression of PPARγ receptors. Liver cell-related steatosis
induces fibrosis progression also through ROS accumulation. Hyperleptinaemia
with insulin resistance may play a role in the activation of hepatic stellate
cells and fibrosis progression. In insulin resistance the TNFα production is
enhanced in patients with hepatitis C and the increased level of TNFα initiates
the fibrosis progression, owing to their ability to activate HSC and promote
collagen deposits. Moreover, TNFα may inhibit PPARγ activity. An impaired
expression of PPARγ receptors was found in patients with hepatitis C. PPARγ
agonists inhibit inflammation and fibrosis progression by blocking the
activation of the redox-sensitive transcription factor NF-κB and TGFβ1 [452].
The presence of steatosis not only significantly
influences the
natural history of patients with chronic hepatitis C, but the anti-viral
response in these cases is highly decreased. While the sustained virological
response is ∼ 60% of
patients with hepatitis C infection without liver steatosis after 1 year
peginterferon-alpha plus ribavirin treatment, this effect is only 30% with
liver steatosis in HCV infection with genotype 1. Hepatic steatosis is a high
risk factor for reduced response to anti-viral treatment and for evolution
towards fibrosis. Obesity and fibrosis represent major therapeutic targets, in
association with standard anti-viral regimes, like insulin-sensitizing drugs
and free radical scavengers (silymarin, ursodeoxycholic acid, metadoxine);
furthermore, the life mode with weight loss can help in therapy efficiency [447,453]. Body-weight reduction and hepatoprotective drugs might have
increased the effectivity of combined peginterferon and ribavirin treatment,
and thus the sustained virological response.
Alcoholic liver disease
Both acute and chronic alcohol consumption
enhances the
production of ROS, with the peroxidation of lipids, proteins and DNA. The
mechanism by which alcohol causes cell injury is very similar to those observed
in non-alcoholic steatohepatitis. Many pathways have been demonstrated in the
literature for the alcohol effect, like the oxidative stress, acetaldehyde
production, mitochondrial alterations, membrane injury, apoptosis,
ethanol-induced hypoxia, effects on the immune system and altered cytokine
production, increased endotoxin levels and activation of Kupffer cells,
mobilization of iron, changes in the antioxidant defence, particularly
mitochondrial glutathione (GSH), one electron oxidation of ethanol to 1-hydroxy-ethyl
radical and induction of CYP2E1. These pathways are not exclusive of one
another and it is likely that many systems contribute to the ability of ethanol
to induce a state of oxidative stress [447,453,454].
Hepatocellular carcinoma
Hepatocellular carcinoma can develop in all kind of chronic
liver diseases. The connections of the different factors are shown in Figure 12. In NAFLD the possible follow-up of the pathogenetic trends is:
increased fatty acid fluxus, the increased fatty acid content in the liver
(VLDL over-production, dyslipidaemia), advanced oxidation and peroxidation in
fatty acids, highly increased free radical production (insufficient antioxidant
capacity), flow out of inflammatory and immune reactive mediators (the changes
in transcription and translation helping the progression of fibrosis) and
finally the carcinogenesis.
In
conclusion, oxidative stress plays a very important role in most chronic liver
diseases, mainly in alcoholic and non-alcoholic steatohepatitis and liver
cirrhosis, furthermore in chronic viral hepatitis, especially in chronic
hepatitis C as well as in primary hepatocellular cancer (HCC). The diagnostic
biomarkers to the clinical praxis can be seen in Table III.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
Evolutionary patterns in production of saturated and unsaturated fats--jk
Evolution operates to maximize survival, and thus the type of
energy storage is balanced by costs. For a variety of reasons animals and plants use carbohydrates and fats for
energy. Major factors for which is stored include durability, ease of conversion to the energy molecule ATP, bulk
of material stored, and energy expended in their synthesis.
So why do animals store fats? In the form of glycogen,
carbohydrates are six times as bulky per calorie of energy; thus fats offer a survival advantage over glycogen. But
for plants they don’t move, thus carbohydrates are the preferred source of energy storage, except for seeds where size
matters. Secondly, most insects prefer for food carbohydrates thus reducing the number of seeds lost to insects.
So why animals make and store
saturated fats. They are stable; i.e., they are not subject to rancidity, while polyunsaturated fats have the highest rate and monounsaturated
a modest rate. The rate of oxidation increases with number of double bonds. Just like the unnatural
trans-fats, rancid fats cannot be metabolized for energy; thus they clog up cells. Rancid and trans-fats have major
negative health consequences including that they are atherogenic. Animals are long lived, and the damage is cumulative,
thus saturated fats provide a survival advantage over polyunsaturated fats. Scientists have demonstrated that saturated fats
are much better for you than unsaturated fats. But what we are told repeatedly about fats is the opposite to what has been
convincingly demonstrated.
So why do we hear from the opinion leaders and government that
polyunsaturated fats are better than saturated fats? The lie is a product of tobacco science and corporate
influence. It is the manufactured foods and grain producing industries that promote plant derived oils and a high
sugar diet. Prof Miller accurately summarizes how tobacco science has come to dominate. Watch his graphically
entertaining lecture to an audience of physicians on YouTube. The voice and financial clout of corporations follows the pattern of tobacco ethics, which
operates counter to the public’s best interest. And it gets worse. Eating less fat entails eating
more carbs for energy. Another chorus of scientist has gone public about the health disaster caused by the Western diet
which includes in the U.S. an average of over 150 pounds of sugar per year per person. Yet the evidence showing
health harm by the combo of sugar and refined carbs has been by industries KOLs, government regulators, and the corporate
media.
So why for their seeds do plants make mostly make polyunsaturated
fats (with the exception of trees)? Saturated fats require more energy to produce, thus under certain conditions
they are favored. Most seeds will under normal moist condition germinate only during the first year or two. These
plants are short lived compared to trees. With trees their long life entails much different evolutionary forces: the
number of oak trees is far less than for corn and soya bean plants, and the replacement rate is in decades versus a year. The
survival pressures for trees entails that their seeds need to survival for years. Thus trees make the more stable
saturated and monounsaturated fats for their seeds. This is why cocoanuts make a high level of saturated, there
seeds are relatively long live, while plants such as soya beans, sunflowers, and canola make mostly polyunsaturated fats,
their seeds are short live, and thus oxidation of the oil in the seed do not have major effect upon germination. The coconut will germinate years later.
|