Hemscott Report at http://www.hemscott.com/news/latest-news/item.do?newsId=52587579801870
AstraZeneca's CORONA trial shows Crestor adds no extra benefit for patients
LONDON (Thomson Financial) - AstraZeneca PLC's long-awaited 'CORONA' trial examining the possible benefits of the
company's Crestor heart product has failed to show any additional benefit for patients when used in addition to the leading
heart treatment, the company said.
Patients taking Crestor had an average 8 pct improved prognosis, but this was not statistically significant, Astra
said.
The widely predicted result means that AstraZeneca has to find other ways of extending Crestor's patent life.
Crestor sales in the year-to-date were 2 bln usd, the company said. julian.hofmann@thomson.com jh1/slj
The Wall Street Journal at http://blogs.wsj.com/health/2007/11/05/crestor-comes-up-short-in-heart-failure/
November 5, 2007, 8:01 am
Crestor Comes Up Short in Heart Failure
Posted by Ron Winslow
In the statin wars, there’s little question that AstraZeneca’s cholesterol-lowering
drug Crestor is the most powerful when it comes to lowering LDL, the bad cholesterol, and giving a boost to good HDL.
But the company lacks–and craves–for Crestor what arch-rival Pfizer has
for Lipitor, the world’s biggest selling drug, and what Merck and Bristol-Myers long had for their now off-patent statins:
hard data that the effect on patients’ cholesterol reduces deaths, heart attacks and other consequences of heart disease. {Evidence strongly suggest that it is the effect upon thrombus that lowers the death
rate. The same may be obtained with aspirin—jk}
Today, researchers are reporting results of the AstraZeneca’s 5,011-patient Corona
trial testing Crestor in heart failure patients, and the company still hasn’t found what it was looking for. During
nearly three years of follow-up, patients taking Crestor had an 8% reduction in the combined outcomes death from cardiovascular
causes and non-fatal heart attacks and strokes compared to placebo. That difference wasn’t large enough to be statistically
significant.
Heart failure seems an unlikely spot to test a statin–evidence
that cholesterol levels play a role in the disease is sparse. But AstraZeneca’s challenge was that the benefits
of statins were already well-established in coronary artery disease by such landmark trials as Merck’s 4S study and
Bristol-Myers Care study. What was left to try?
“It was hardly ethical to do a placebo-controlled trial” in already established
areas of statin benefit, Michael Cressman, executive director, strategic development for Crestor at AstraZeneca, told the
Health Blog at the American Heart Association’s science meeting in Orlando where the Corona data were unveiled this
morning. And a head-to-head study against Lipitor, for instance, would have required tens of thousands of patients, with no
assurance that Crestor would prove substantially better at reducing deaths and heart attacks.
The Corona data have a few positives for
Crestor. The drug reduced heart-related hospitalization, and the study didn’t find any evidence that statins might harm
patients with heart failure–a previously unanswered and controversial question. But in the Corona
study deaths from heart failure, which typically result from irregular heart beats caused by abnormalities in the heart’s
electrical system dominated over deaths from artery blockages, plumbing problems that statins help prevent.
“Coming into the statin world as late as we did made it very difficult,”
Cressman says. “The low-hanging fruit had already been picked.”
Those who have a financial interest in the outcome manipulate the results, Major study finds that all 37 journal articles positive effects over stated; the average was 32%. Statins cause erectile
dysfunction, cognitive imparement, and cancer.
Lipitor (2011) lifetime sales $131
billion, tops all drugs. Plavix at
$60 billion is second.
STATINS CANCER Link
52% short term
LA Times, Health section, July 21, 2008 -- excerpts
Vytorin, the
combination drug (simvastatin (better known by its commercial name Zocor) and ezetimibe--known as Zetia) prescribed to lower
cholesterol, sustained another blow today, when the author of a major clinical trial announced that the medication had failed
to drive down hospitalization and death due to heart failure in patients with narrowing of the aortic valve. In the process,
researchers in Norway detected a significant blip in cancers in the 1,800 subjects they followed
Today's findings
suggested something more ominous: the incidence of cancer -- and of dying of cancer -- was significantly higher in the patients
taking Vytorin. Altogether, 67 patients on placebo developed cancer during the trial.
Among subjects on Vytorin, 102 developed cancers of various kinds.* This
is the second adverse press—the first being in March 08, when the ENHANCE trial found that Vytorin fared no better than
a placebo at reducing plaque buildup on the walls of patients' arteries.* *
Comments
by jk
Simvastatin (Zocor) is off patent. Thus in a scramble for profits a combination drug (on patent) was introduced. Direct to consumer market cost $155 in 07—mainly TV ads.
*
The pressing issue is that since the development of Statins, the very
first animal studies in the 60s it has been known that Statins increase the incidents of cancer. However, nearly all studies done thereafter have not included cancer.
*
Several studies have failed to find a reduction in the build of plaque, even thought the statins including Zocor, reduce
LDL and cholesterol. Few studies include the
principle reason for taking a statin, namely a reduction in the death rate. Claims
for such reduction probably entail a failure to control the contravening variable, aspirin usage. Given a pile of evidence, including the very mechanism of plaque formation, which involves inflammation
process, I must conclude that the use of statins is highly suspect. Given the
harm done including cognitive impairment, weakness, and cancer, if my skepticism is born out, the harm done by statins as
a course of treatment will far surpass that of VIOXX which killed over 200,000 people world wide by accelerating atherosclerosis.
EXTENDED RELEASE NIACIN IS A SAFER, AND A MORE EFFECTIVE WAY TO LOWER
MI RISK!
|